American Puritanism has its beginning in sixteenth-century England. King Henry VIII (1509-1547) shook the Church in England loose from its Roman Catholic moorings. The two brief reigns that followed muddied the waters: during the reign of Edward VI (1547-1553) the nation veered sharply toward Protestantism; in the reign of Mary I, nicknamed “Bloody Mary” (1553-1558), it veered even more sharply back toward Rome.
In the long reign of Queen Elizabeth I (1558–1603), citizens caught their collective breath and tried to determine, more precisely, the character of their new national Church. It is not surprising that people differed – strongly, bitterly, and even bloodily.
Some passionately sought to make the Protestant Reformation a redeeming reality in all of English life and culture, thus purifying it. They came to be called Puritans. The Puritans wanted to rid the Church of England of all evidences of its historic Catholic connection, and to let the New Testament determine Church order and worship. As petitioners to King James I (1603-1625) put it in 1603, the true Church should not be “governed by Popish Canons, Courts, Classes, Customs, or any human invention, but by the laws and rules which Christ hath appointed in His Testament.”
But Puritans themselves soon split as to the method of purifying. Puritanism has become a label. For some, “what is wrong with America” is that too much Puritanism survives to haunt and inhibit their country. Other Americans, though, believe the failures of our country result from the dilution of Puritan discipline and ideals. Whether one thinks of Puritanism as a blessing or a curse, this is sure: no religious experiment in the New World has had a more enduring impact upon our nation’s education, literature, sense of mission, Church governance, ethical responsibility, or religious vision.
After three months at sea, the first American Puritans, the Pilgrims, landed in December 1620. Governor William Bradford wrote, “They had now no friends to welcome them nor inns to entertain or refresh their weatherbeaten bodies; no houses or much less towns to repair to.… And for the season, it was winter.… What could they see but a hideous and desolate wilderness?… What could now sustain them but the Spirit of God and his grace?”
While some had worked patiently to reform the Church in England, others gave up hope that such a political megachurch would ever change. So they separated from the national Church in order to fashion a fellowship of their own, with the New Testament as their only guide.
One Separatist congregation meeting in secret in Nottingham (north of London) hoped that the new king, James I, would be more lenient in religious matters than Elizabeth had been. But those hopes were dashed when James declared that all dissenters must conform to England’s worship and submit to England’s bishops, or “I will harry them out of the land, or else worse.” “Worse” clearly meant “death,” for failure to conform to the Church of England was a capital crime. Yet to conform was impossible for these men and women.
In 1607 the group fled to Holland, (including the grandparents of Benjamin Franklin) where they could worship in a manner that did not violate their consciences. After some years, however, they found that solution unsatisfactory; their children, burdened with difficult labor, were growing up as Dutch young people, not as English.
Aware of English claims in the New World, the Pilgrims (as these Separatists became known) conceived the ambitious and expensive plan to start a colony across the sea. They received a land grant from the Virginia Company of London and some promise of merchant support, though neither came easily. The Pilgrims had to prove they were not radical heretics; the merchants had to be assured that some return on their investments would be forthcoming.
Being “knit together as a body in a most strict and sacred bond and covenant of the Lord,” the group of about 100 sailed from Plymouth, England, on September 6, 1620. Two months later, the Mayflower arrived off Cape Cod in Massachusetts, where these settlers soon established their own Plymouth.
The Virginia Company’s patent extended roughly around the southern tip of Manhattan Island. The new arrivals thus realized they needed some instrument of civil government, especially since some of their number, not sharing the same religious fervor, had made “discontented and mutinous speeches.” The resulting Mayflower Compact, dated November 11, 1620, pledged the group, “solemnly mutually in the presence of God and one another,” to “covenant, and combine ourselves together into a civil body politic.” The good of the colony, not the interests of any individual, was to be the guiding principle.
Maranatha!
(mar-uh-nath-uh – “Our Lord Comes”)
Pastor Steve can be reached at PastorSteve@MaranathaBibleChurch.org